Video Discussion Guide 

Discovery Atlantis

1996, color, 54 minutes, Discovery Channel 

Summary 

Few myths  have been so powerful as that of the lost continent or city of Atlantis. A creation of Plato,  in his Timeaus Plato has Egyptian priests of Sais converse with his ancestor Solon, and tell him of a country larger than Asia Minor and Lybia together, the seat of a magnificent civilization far out in the western sea. In his Critias Plato tells more of Atlantis, whose king ruled parts of Europe as far as the Baltic, Caspian and Black seas. Atlantis had nearly 12,000,000 people. Its civilization was wondrous. It all perished in a powerful calamity and sank beneath the sea. 

Although most scholars interpret Atlantis to be an allegory of a Utopia, never having existed at all, some have believed it to be true and have sought it. Some believe it to be based on the Minoan civilization that controlled the Mediterranean and beyond, that collapsed after the destruction of Thera and associated volcanic eruptions and tidal waves. The video explores this hypothesis, interviewing Greek archaeologist Christos Doumas. Still others look at Troy as its genesis. 

Some have believed Plato's account to be an  accurate statement of geography, with the location in the western sea, beyond the Pillars of Hercules (Gibraltar). The video examines the possibility that the reference is to the Americas. Specifically, the video looks at length at the site of Tiahuanaco in the Lake Titicaca region of Bolivia. Many comparisons are made with the warning that Tiahuanaco is recent made only at the start of discussion and again at the end. With the site being so recent, comparisons are made to the Olmec civilizations and its proposed connections to Africa (based on the features of the Olmec heads). 

Other contacts between Old and New Worlds is explored, particularly recent evidence of cocaine and nicotine supposedly found in Egyptian mummies. Most of these evidences are spotty and have problems. In the end, the narrator comments that it is okay to dream about finding Atlantis, with Christos Doumas noting that it is only a dream, and that Atlantis is something inside us, not existing in the real world. 

Questions 

  1. What problems of  fact are apparent in the video?
  2. What devices does the video use to connect Tiahuanaco and Atlantis? Is this rare or common in the video?
  3. What are the problems with transoceanic contact between Old and New World? What is the evidence of it?
  4. Why is the Atlantis myth so powerful?

 


| Main | Outline | Brief | Brief Schedule | Debunking Tools | Video Guides | Projects | Final |


larry-zimmerman@uiowa.edu
University of Iowa Anthropology

08/18/98